Maria Hutchings has stuck two fingers up to her critics in the media by giving Eastleigh News an exclusive first post-election interview after losing to Lib Dem Mike Thornton and being pushed into third place after a late surge to Ukip
During a relaxed interview over a couple of beers at the Toby Carvery (Mike Thornton country) Hutchings insisted she had not been gagged and revealed she had been on the receiving end of hate mail following the publication of a “hugely damaging” story about her son’s education. She also believes Ukip’s success in Eastleigh is unlikely to be repeated and that there is no need for the Conservative party to ‘lurch to the right’.
The feisty West End mum of four – who had previously contested the seat in 2010 – would not rule out standing a third time in Eastleigh in the 2015 General Election.
Maria Hutchings arrived to the interview accompanied by loyal husband Stuart. Now free of the retinue of reporters, photographers, SPADs, interns and press officers the couple looked considerably happier since the last time Eastleigh News saw them at the Fleming Park declaration being ruthlessly pursued by a media lynch mob.
Maria’s entourage had piled into ‘getaway’ cars pausing only to extricate a photographer who had wedged a foot in the door and to evict another one who had clambered in with them before roaring off – not realising that in their haste to escape that they had left hubby Stuart behind who then had to walk home from Eastleigh to West End at three in the morning.
As Hutchings was escorted out of the count by her team, a barrage of questions “Have you been gagged” “Why won’t you talk?” “Who do you blame?” were met with no comment from her – just a frozen smile.
Now, with the pressure off, Maria Hutchings is prepared to talk and its going to be hard to stop her.
“It’s not the party’s fault and I was never gagged. There was never any point where I was told you can’t speak about this or “this is the message you have to give”.
“The national press had come to town and they wanted a story. I was a candidate with history because of my previous special needs campaigning. I’d been all over the national press before and I was easy pickings .”
Why didn’t you stop and speak to press on your way out of the count? You were smiling but not speaking?
“Yes I came out smiling but what have the press written? That I was ‘tearful’ and ‘emotional’.
“There were 136 press passes given out on the night and even though Mike Thornton won and Ukip had done much better than anybody had expected the entire press pack was around me, so close that I could hardly walk or breathe. There were cables rounds people’s legs – desks being knocked over.
“ I thought ‘I have given you all five years of my life’ and in the last three weeks I had given them every interview they wanted. I just decided: ‘I am not going to give you anymore. I don’t want to speak and I’m not going to. Job done. I was a candidate I’ve lost and now it’s over – that’s democracy.’ ”
” Somebody in my team said ‘I’ve been doing politics for 30 years I ‘ve been with Boris and I’ve been out with the PM but I’ve never seen a media attack like that before’.”
In fact Hutchings is less than happy with her press coverage in general:
“My national press coverage during the campaign’ was abysmal – though not by every journalist – but the press were keen on talking about how short my skirt was or about me ‘imploding’, or making up stories about my views on state education which were spun then twisted.
“You get to a point where you can’t fight these stories because it turns into a polemic you give the story legs and it becomes the story. I always wanted to keep to local issues”
Quotes had been attributed to Hutchings following a Daily Mail interview which suggested she didn’t think state education was good enough for her son who wanted to be a surgeon. This in turn, had sparked outrage in the press and social media forcing her to publicly express her support for local schools.
Do you think the school story was damaging?
“Hugely damaging. Not least to me personally. It really hurt.”
“I had a Daily Mail journalist in my home doing a feature article which was fantastic and what I said to her was that when my third child William was three and a half he did his child development tests with our health visitor and on verbal ability he was deemed to be advanced”
“I went to a state school head and asked what we should do about this – we were living in Essex at the time not Hampshire – and he said we should look for a local school with a good gifted list.”
“I wanted to give my son the best chance – like anybody else would. The other option was to go private – both Stuart and I had gone to state schools as have our other children. We wouldn’t have considered it if our son hadn’t been classed as gifted or unless we had been advised to”.
“In the end my son won an academic scholarship to a school that could meet his needs”
“At the end of the Daily Mail interview I added as an amusing aside that my son who is now 12 years- told told me he wants to be a cardio-respiratory surgeon. I find this comical as it is so precise but after it was reported in the Daily Mail another newspaper was able to take it and spin it and ask why wasn’t Wildern or Wyvern good enough for my child.”
“But that wasn’t the truth of the story – I never said that.
“What was never mentioned is that my fourth child Harriet is on the list for Wildern and Wyvern.”
Hutchings said she was upset at the negative publicity the story generated which resulted in abusive texts, tweets and emails.
She claimed one person emailed and said “I hope you become disabled and die” and that she also received an MSM message on her phone “which said they wanted to see me to die like Stephen Milligan”. (The last Conservative MP for Eastleigh who died in bizarre circumstances).
Ironically, Mrs Hutchings said that following her electoral loss, her son William – the boy at the heart of the row – came home from school and said
“I don’t want to upset you Mum but I have been elected to the school council”
Do you think it was a mistake not to do the hustings organised by Radio 5 and 38 degrees?”
“Well 38 degrees no. The people who attend hustings tend to have made they mind up about who they are going to vote for any way and at that late stage of the campaign it’s important to meet with undecided voters or to try and ensure those who do support you are going to turn out. That’s what my focus was more on at that stage but the hustings also clashed with a surgery we had already organised in Hamble. Contrary to Lib Dem claims that Conservatives are in favour, I am opposed to gravel extraction at Hamble and I campaign against it. I felt it was important to make sure that message was getting across by continuing to support residents who are fighting the plan.
“I have previously been on Radio 5 Live before, speaking about special needs education and all manner of policy hundreds of times and I would have ideally have liked to do it because I respect Radio 5 and their debates but we had the Prime Minister coming down to Prysmian who are a fantastic hi-tech company locally. They employ hundreds of skilled people and they are on the up. We opened a £2 million lab there that day. It was more important to me to be there with the Prime Minister to get exposure for a local business and also to listen to the hundreds of people who had come there.”
“There is no way physically I could have done the radio debate and then got to Prysmian and have done a good job of both them.”
The press noticed you didn’t always seem to be on the same page as the PM on issues like the EU or same sex marriage and you weren’t taking questions when he visited
“I wasn’t told I couldn’t take questions – I quickly learned the press had come to talk to the Prime Minister of the country. How many times do you get that opportunity -particularly if you are local press?
“But I could never win. At the beginning I was the ‘loose cannon’ because I said what I thought and it wasn’t party policy but then later I was criticised for not speaking.
“I am a loose cannon in the sense that I would always speak my mind and I would have always put the people of Eastleigh first. I have no aspiration to be a minister or go any further.
“My aspirations were to represent the people here in Parliament and get the best deal for them.
“I was branded a loose cannon by the press after being asked historical questions on conscience votes like abortion and same sex marriage, they then decided to go with the story that I was being gagged and they decided that agenda and there wasn’t any way that I could have fought it even though what I really wanted to get across that this was a local constituency campaign – it was about local issues.”
I reminded Mrs Hutchings that Keith House’s favourite BBC reporter, Michael Crick, had asked her about House of Lords reform on day one of her campaign:
“It was a real shock question because I hadn’t considered it. I thought this was a local campaign – my thoughts on the House of Lords is yes, it needs reforming but people in Eastleigh are more concerned about building on green field sites, parking charges or the gravel pit in Hamble rather than the way the constitution is being run.
“A by-election for me is where you choose a local MP to listen to people who live here who understands their problems and is there to defend their interests. A national general election is when you decide who runs the country and the press ran with the national agenda as they have a national readership that they want to feed and that is so wrong.
“You don’t get to set the agenda with the press. You can tell the press what you want and they will print what they want.”
A clearly frustrated Hutchings went on:
“I believe we need an MP that would be able to hold the local council to account. There is no way we can overturn 40 borough councillors in one go but if we had an MP in Parliament who was not a Liberal Democrat we would be able to better defend the interests of local people.
“I just wish more people had realised this.”
When did she realise she had lost the election?
“All the way through the campaign right up to the last minute I thought I would win. Why? Because lifelong Lib Dem and Labour voters were telling me on the doorstep they would vote for me because of the campaigns that I’d run and the meetings I’d set up on local issues that mattered to them. In telephone polling at the start of the election my name had an 80% recognition with voters.
“On the day of the election our returns were coming in from people who had been telling all day and by the afternoon we should have had a rough idea if we were getting the vote out and where the votes were coming from. I wasn’t getting enough feedback but I was being told that it was still ‘so close’.
“People weren’t sure. In fact when the first few boxes of sampling were opened at the count my vote was really holding up. Yes there were loads of new Ukip votes but not so much for the Lib Dems – everything changed for me when the postal vote boxes opened.
“The Ukip vote didn’t surprise me as by-elections are an opportunity for a protest vote – as one journalist put it “Eastleigh indulged itself”
“If you look at the Ukip vote they took about a third of the Conservative vote but the rest of it was Labour, Liberal and new voters. All you had to do was to go out to Bishopstoke and Eastleigh to where all the Ukip posters were which were the areas where those protest voters would be – what really surprised me was the Lib Dem vote.”
“Liberal democrats were once the protest vote now it is Ukip and when it comes to the general I don’t think the Ukip vote will bear up in Eastleigh as much as anywhere else. I think it will go right down.”
Keith House has said much the same thing and he says it’s still going to be between the Conservatives and the Lib Dems in Eastleigh – you seem to agree with him?
“Well, that’s a first!”
“I would not like to predict but it is important to recognise that Ukip’s result is a protest vote rather than lurching to the right.”
Do you think the Conservative party should move further to the right?
“I have always thought the party should be strong on immigration. If you look back at the earliest articles that were being written about me in 2006 and 2005 I was being called a racist because I talked about open door immigration – though for me it is not about race. It is about making sure that the limited services we have like housing health education that the people in this country who have paid into the system all their lives people who have served this country actually get the return that they put in
“I have always fought on Europe. If we had a referendum today on Europe I would want to be out. We are spending £53million on Europe a day and I can think of far better places we could put that money but I think we should wait on a referendum until David Cameron renegotiates, to see what happens.
“As far as a lurch to the right goes only a third of the Ukip vote are former Conservative voters that tells me that concerns on the EU and immigration aren’t confined to Conservative supporters.
“I think we should focus on immigration and Europe because I have been on the doorstep for five years and those are the issues people are concerned about but I don’t think it deserves a ‘lurch to the right’.”
“I think we should be focusing on jobs, jobs, jobs – the economy – making sure we have enough apprenticeships, making sure people are educated in the right skills so we don’t even have to consider people from other countries.
“Ukip were offering voters a magic wand but we are in Europe and while we are in Europe we cannot have a moratorium on immigration.
“Net immigration from outside the EU is actually higher than immigration from within the EU. What the Conservatives have done is to bring in measures to bring immigration down by a third and we’ve got policies on sham marriages in place and also for bogus students. If immigration is the biggest issue in Eastleigh then why did the Lib Dems win?”
“The Liberal Democrats want an amnesty for thousands of illegal immigrants – they’re trying to stop our strict controls on immigration – they don’t want to give us a referendum on Europe.”
Is there anything you would have changed about the campaign and the way it was run?
“No. I believe I have always acted in the best interests of Eastleigh people in all the different campaigns whether it was the Sainsbury’s expansion on to Eastleigh Rec or the gravel pits. I always put them first beyond party and I truly felt I would be able to get those votes out
“What I would like to change is the electoral process in this country. I find it ridiculous that you can walk into to a polling station without any form of identification and vote. I find it ridiculous that we have a postal vote that happens midway through a three week by-elections when we haven’t been through the whole campaign and when smaller parties who have entered the field later on would not have had the opportunity to build up postal votes the way for example the Liberal Democrats have.
“I don’t see transparency in this and I would love to see a tightening up of electoral process so virtually everybody has to go to the polling station with Identification to vote.”
Maria also said she did not think it was right that a political party should be able to distribute postal vote application forms along with their campaign literature – and the sheer volume of leaflets also came in for criticism:
“People were sick to death of this by-election by the time we got to polling day. God knows how many trees were cut down for the by election. Had I got elected one of the issues I wanted to take up was that elections should be an even playing field for every party, however small or large, and we wouldn’t have the problems of donations to parties if we curtailed this ability to put large numbers of leaflets through people’s doors. We’ve got the internet now and every party has their own campaign website up plus there is social media. For people who haven’t got access to computers then the Royal Mail could deliver one or two pieces of literature for each party as they do now.
“I have spoken to so many people who say “I vote Lib Dem because they send me a news letter and they keep me in touch” for me that is no the right reason to vote.”
Maria Hutchings wasn’t very happy with press treatment of the local conservative party association either:
“I have taken umbrage at the national press referring to the ‘weakness’ of the local Conservative Party Association.
“How did we get over 21,000 votes in 2010 with a tiny fraction of the help we had in this by-election? We got these votes because of the hard work we did here and we may not be great in numbers but not many local associations in any parties are now.”
“Our association has worked so hard I will not have anyone thrash it.”
Would you stand again?
“I loved the by-election I really enjoyed it. I would definitely have done these past three weeks all over again.”
“ In politics you have to develop the skin of rhino otherwise you don’t survive. As to what happens in the future it’s not up to me whether I stand in Eastleigh, it will be up to the association.”
More posts about Maria Hutchings here
More posts on Eastleigh By-election here





