Mike Thornton has held on to Chris Huhne’s seat for the Lib Dems, surviving a collapse in the Lib Dem vote, in what was the lowest election turnout since Eastleigh’s very first election night in 1955.
In a tense night at the Fleming Park Leisure centre last Thursday, under the glare of the nations media, Ukip dramatically improved on its 2010 general election performance by coming in a close second place- a result predicted by the polls and the bookies.
Just 52.8% of eligible voters – 41,616 people – voted (the record is 82% in 1974) and of those just 32% (13,342 votes) went to Mike Thornton.
This is 14.44% – or 11,624 votes – fewer than Huhne collected in 2010 and meant that on the night, the Lib Dems lost more votes than any other party.
Even so, Thornton claimed the result showed the “People of Eastleigh” had given him a ‘mandate’ – although he had actually polled just 17% of the registered voters or 10.5% of Eastleigh’s total population.
Despite there being only 1,800 votes separating the Lib Dems from Ukip and a reduction in vote share of almost 15% jubilant Lib Dems celebrated as if they had won an historic landslide with well rehearsed party workers and councillors holding placards aloft while chanting a “We love Mike”.

They gave Thornton and his wife Peta a rapturous welcome with more Lib Dem councillors there cheering his win then were present at the council’s budget setting meeting just two days previously when 25 Lib Dem members (including Thornton) had failed to show up.
Ukip on the up
You could also have been forgiven for thinking Ukip had won from the size of the press scrum around them from the moment they arrived at the count.
To come a close second – pushing out the Conservatives after finishing a distant nowhere three years ago- is a huge achievement but If leader Nigel Farage had any regrets about not having contested the seat himself then he wasn’t showing it as he stood next to his candidate Dianne James, beaming broadly.

James had proven herself to be not just a surrogate for Farage but a more than capable – if somewhat controversial – contender in her own right.
A win in Eastleigh – and the resulting media profile that would have gone with it – would have surely made her an inevitable leadership rival.
James told me she intended to contest Eastleigh again – word is that Farage intends to field her as a candidate in the Euro elections next year – an election in which Ukip should sweep the board as it seems it is only their growing membership that can be bothered to vote in the Euros.
Ukip have lost both their female MEPs Nikki Sinclair and Marta Andreasen both of whom resigned from the party so it would make sense.
Ukip held an impromptu press conference in the counting hall with the BBC’s political correspondent Peter Henley asking the questions.
“What message does this send to the conservative party?”
Wondered Henley.
“What Conservative Party?” replied Farage
“The conservative party under David Cameron has become a social democrat party – which Conservative voters in Eastleigh can’t recognise anymore”

Farage’s responses made Peter Henley laugh
Farage clearly relished chastising Tory voters for splitting the Ukip vote – neatly turning round a criticism constantly levelled at Ukip in conservative marginal’s throughout the country
A Ukip spokesman said at the start of the count they were positive they had done well at the polling booths but did not know if it was enough to overturn the postal vote deficit.
Over 14,000 postal votes had been issued after Lib Dems had delivered postal voting applications across the Borough – conventional wisdom calls these votes for the Lib Dems.
Ukip had campaigned hard on EU immigration issues – although the 2011 census data shows only 1,000 immigrants from the EU accession counties have actually settled in Eastleigh since 2001, James was predicting millions of Romanians and Bulgarians coming to the UK.
Statistics show that Eastleigh enjoys below average unemployment, above average wages with crime rates low and falling but when Mike Thornton quoted police crime figures during a hustings, Ukip’s Dianne James said police crime statistics were unreliable but then minutes later used police crime statistics to link Romanian immigrants with criminality.
Whatever the truth, a large number of Eastleigh voters clearly identified with Ukip’s message and the uncompromising way candidate Dianne James delivered it.
“I’m sorry if I sound Draconian or not liberal enough for some people”
she said at the 38 degrees hustings.
Around 55% of people who told pollsters they would vote Ukip said that immigration was a key issue for them – even though David Cameron has promised an EU referendum and although the Conservative candidate Maria Hutchings said she was in favour of EU withdrawl and tighter immigration controls voters no longer appear to trust the Conservatives on immigration – a point Farage rammed home.
Hutchings concedes deafeat
The arrival of Conservative candidate Maria Hutchings created an equal fuss – but for the wrong reasons. She wasn’t stopping for any interviews and there was a fair amount of pushing and shoving as minders tried to force a way through the press pack, all of whom wanted a close up of the night’s big loser.

Hutchings arrives at count with Carrie Symonds (Johnson)
Hutching’s had an early lead in the campaign with the pollsters and bookies. A local candidate who had busied herself by supporting various campaigning groups in the constituency, she claimed to be just an ordinary working mum who understood and spoke for the people of Eastleigh.
On paper it looked like a shoo in.
However good deeds seldom go unpunished.
Perhaps if the campaign had been fought solely on local issues she may have won but instead she was beaten into third place by Dianne James who hails from well heeled Ewhurst in Surrey (most famous resident millionaire sniffle guitarist Eric Clapton) and would seem to have little in common with the majority of Eastleigh residents and had never attended a single local protest march or signed a single petition.
Although Hutchings had played a long game to establish herself as a genuine campaigning local, in the end she was beaten by a complete outsider no one in Eastleigh had ever heard of four weeks ago.
Things began to go wrong for Hutchings during the campaign after she showed herself to be unashamedly ‘off message’ on topics like immigration and EU membership which resulted in her central office advisers closely managing her appearances. She was pulled out of two hustings – one a live radio broadcast.
In her last live hustings appearance the debate ended in uproar and shouting as she simultaneously attacked Mike Thornton over Woodhouse Lane while attempting to defend herself from hecklers in the audience demanding to know where she would put housing.

It can be lonely in opposition
During last Thursday’s count the four member Conservative group on Eastleigh Borough Council had cut lonely, isolated figures. For them the result was academic. In the 1950’s and 1960s Conservative votes from the wards they represent in Hiltingbury and Chandler’s Ford kept Labour out and Sir David Price in.
Boundary changes mean those votes now fall under the Winchester constituency where they helped Conservative MP Steve Brine defeat the Lib Dems – those votes would have made all the difference.
O’Farrell bows out

There was no grand entrance for Labour candidate John O’Farrell and even the Raving Loonies had created a bigger stir. Viewed solely in terms of voting percentage, Labour actually increased their share slightly by 0.22% – but it was still their worst ever result here. They were squeezed into fourth for the first time ever with the lowest number of votes they had ever received in this constituency – just 4,088 votes.
In 1966 they had polled 23,636.
It seemed hard to imagine that O’Farrell could have turned in a worse result than the 2010 candidate Leo Barraclough – and at one point Labour was running in third place according to bookies but in the end it was hardly any better than 2010, even though O’Farrell had the benefit of being chaperoned by three MPs, had received visits from dozens of other MPs (including the entire shadow cabinet) and had hundreds of activists bussed in from all around the country to help.
Leo Barraclough had managed to achieve a similar result with just a handful of local branch activists on a total expenditure of just £3,125.
One wonders if the Labour vote has now shrunk to its core of die hard loyalists who will vote Labour anyway regardless of who the candidate is.
Interestingly both the 2010 and 2013 candidates were in many similar. Both were writers – middle class types with bohemian showbizzy backgrounds and came from well outside the area with little local knowledge.
O’Farrell was a far more articulate though – and produced some of the most memorable quips of the campaign including the observation:
“Its not immigrants who are closing shops in Eastleigh”
What really de-railed the Labour campaign though was the revelation that some years ago O’Farrell had published some tasteless remarks about Thatcher, the Brighton Bombing and the Falklands.
While the press had a field day O’Farrell’s credibility was irreparably damaged and he has since announced that he will not stand in the 2015 general election.
O’Farrell had wanted to campaign on Labour’s ‘One Nation’ agenda but in hustings found himself sidelined as Hutchings and Thornton slugged it out over planning issues leading O’Farrell to muse that he felt that he was taking part in a ‘faux council election.’
Independent attracts support

The biggest swing of the night went to Independent Danny Stupple.
In 2010 Bishopstoke Independent candidate Dave Stone came last with 154 votes. This time one man band Stupple finished fifth j – behind Labour with 768 votes beating candidates with party organisations, like the English Democrats, TUSC and the National Health Action Party.
Stupple punched the air as the result was read out and said:
“I stood on an issue of redefinition of marriage I pointed out there is a massive disconnect between the local people. I’m just a property surveyor who has lived here for 30 years.”
“I love Eastleigh – this is just a beginning for independents in politics.”
Dr Iain MacLennan of the National Heath Action Party came 6th and polled 392 votes said:
“People in Eastleigh have said to me they want a return to the politics of hope rather than the politics of fear and greed.”
Hedge End’s Ray Hall – The Beer, Baccy and Crumpet party – probably the most senior candidate in terms of age and length of residency in the constituency said:
“If the government was to reduce the excise duty on draught beer public houses would be able to compete with the cheap booze that is sold in hypermarkets.”

Ray Hall – Beer,Baccy and Crumpet party
Kevin Milburn of the Christian Party standing for “truth, justice and traditional marriage” polled 163 votes while howling Laud Hope of the Monster raving Loony William Hill party pulled 136.
Hope, who came to the count dressed as Boss Hogg, gave an impromptu vocal performance of ‘Mack the knife” before marvelling that 136 people in Eastleigh had decided to vote for him –surely some mistake.
The raving loony stood so close to Mike Thornton while the Lib Dem was delivering his victory speech TV viewers tuning in must have mistaken him for the returning officer.

STOP SINGING!!! Eastleigh News own Ray Turner remonstrates with Howling Laud Hope
Jim Duggan’s peace party clocked up 128 votes
David Bishop of ‘Elvis Loves Pets’ party told Mike Thornton “You should thank Chris Huhne for resigning” and observed that he had done no campaigning and had only given out 30 leaflets but still got 72 votes.

Elvis loves pets
This was two more than the English Democrats who suffered a – 72% drop in their vote to finish with 70 votes after they had polled 249 votes in 2010.
Disappointed ED candidate Michael Walter said “Voters in Eastleigh should have gone to Specsavers”.
The English Democrats said they suffered after being wrongly linked to the English Defence League. Michael Walter added that the English Democrat party was nonracist and had even stood a Muslim candidate previously. It would seem Ukip have now cornered the market in nationalist voters.

Daz Procter – TUSC
Anti-cuts party TUSC finished 13th and second from bottom. In the end the party which claimed to represent 99% of the population and boasted of being backed by 80,000 RMT workers only polled 62 votes.
One TUSC activist told me that they had contacted most of the major Trade Union reps in Eastleigh in order to secure the support of their membership but were consistently told “Our members don’t vote anymore”.
TUSC candidate Daz Proctor, who had vowed to live on an ordinary workers wage if elected, said:
“We may not have got many votes but we are new party and will continue keep battling for the millions out there living on the poverty line”
This left Colin Bex of the Wessex Regionalists to collect the wooden spoon after getting just 30 votes.
Bex said:
“This has been the most delightful campaign I’ve fought but the people who voted for the winner voted for ‘business as usual’. There are at least 30 intelligent people in Eastleigh who voted for democracy”
Bex promised he would be back to stand candidates all across the region in the general election in 2015.
After the speeches were over press attention quickly refocused on Maria Hutchings. It seemed like all 136 members of the press pack had made a beeline for her and she left the building the same way as she came in – jammed in the middle of a crowd of jostling hacks and reporters – still refusing to stop and talk to them.
This may sound ungracious of her but it was clear that she was disappointed from the quiver in her voice as she conceded defeat and congratulated Thornton . No one wants to break down and sob live on national TV – politicians are, after all, only human.
Hutchings left by a side door where a car was waiting and afterwards we heard a photographer had a car door slammed on his foot as he tried to use it to wedge a door open for a parting shot.
State of the parties
Thursday’s result means the Lib Dems will have to rewrite their slogans. Eastleigh is now a three horse race.
The Lib Dem’s must also surely be asking themselves where nearly 12,000 of their votes went too.
Labour were expecting their fickle voters to transfer their allegiance back to them following the Huhne betrayal but it seems Ukip has stepped in and hoovered up the blue collar vote instead.
A Labour activist confided he hated knocking on doors in Bishopstoke and Fair Oak which he described as a hot bed of Ukipism.
Indeed Eastleigh Ukip has a sitting parish councillor in both areas.
One Ukip activist told me they are strong wherever you find white vans parked in drive ways – Identifying self employed home owning tradesmen is key.
Tradesmen he argued feared competition from East European plumbers and chippies and largely supported the idea of controls on EU immigration.
Labour’s poor result will not affect their national party fortunes. Ed Milliband is still odds on favourite to be the next PM and all the polls still have Labour showing a clear lead but where the local party goes from here is hard to see.
We won’t have to wait long with the County Council elections due in May while local Labour activists claim the by-election experience has ‘rejuvenated’ the constituency party.
As for the Lib Dems they ran the most efficient campaign of the lot and managed to hang on to power but to a large extent this was due to the damage inflicted on the Tory vote by Ukip.
Analysis of recent polls by Yougov has suggested that 60% of Ukip voters previously voted conservative in the 2010 election.
A Ukip spokesman warned they could lose to the Lib Dems on the postal vote and Ukips counting agents saw scant evidence of Ukip votes among the postal returns – most of the postal votes were in before Ukip had distributed its literature. Their campaign did not gain traction until the surge in the final week.
The record low turnout must be cause for concern. For democracy to function there must be participation There were definite signs of voter fatigue during the campaign due to leaflet overkill with notices appearing on doors throughout the constituency telling canvassers and leaflet deliverers to keep away – one conservative activist suggested to Eastleigh News that it was a deliberate negative tactic by the Lib Dems who carpet-bombed voters into apathy through sheer volume of leaflets so they could maximise their core vote.
The political strategist Philip Gould described declining voter participation as an empty stadium scenario where the teams are playing each other in front of empty seats because the spectators have lost interest and gone home.
It will surely be the parties with the largest active membership who will do well in future if turnout numbers continue to dwindle. The Lib Dems have a strong base in the constituency and Ukip certainly have been increasing theirs with over 3,000 enquiries during the campaign
It remains to be seen if ‘New’ Ukip can maintain their momentum through the forthcoming county and local elections – and into the 2014 Euros and the General Election in 2015.
During the campaign Ukip were joined by former Lib Dem councillors Andy Moore and Glynn Davies-Dear. Davies-Dear was also a County Councillor in Eastleigh East for 12 years and served as both f Mayor and as a Bishopstoke Parish Councillor – a seat Mike Thornton announced he would be resigning.
The experience the two ex Lib Dems will bring to Ukip’s local campaigns may provide the party with a breakthrough.
There is no word from the Conservative camp as to whether Hutchings stays as PPC for 2015 – it would not seem likely.
For David Cameron, as Party Leader, the Eastleigh result has ominous implications – for the local constituency party a good showing in the county elections is now vital.
Mike Thornton’s victory speech:
“Firstly I would like to thank the police and all those who worked today on polling stations and this evening at the count and the returning officer Richard Ward.
“This has been a really busy by-election especially by the short notice given for this by election”
“By you” shouted one wag
“ and I thank all of you for playing your part in the smooth running of a huge logistical operation. Secondly I would like to say thank you to all my opponents but particularly Maria, Dianna (sic) and John with whom I’ve had the opportunity to debate under the scrutiny of the national media throughout this election.”
“Thank you for fighting such a – on the whole- reasonable and well mannered campaign focusing on the issues that matter to people here in Eastleigh. and thirdly I’d like to thank my local party and the huge numbers of Liberal Democrat activists and volunteers who have come to Eastleigh to campaign for me over the past four weeks and to the Deputy Prime Minster Nick Clegg whose support and advice have given a tremendous boost both to me and the campaign.
“You have already demonstrated to the nation the effective fighting spirit which is very much a part of our party and I will never ever forget.
“It is very difficult to single out individuals for particular thanks on these occasions but I must thank Keith House my agent and Victoria Carson.
“I’m very proud of the campaign we fought together focussed on the issues that matter to the people in our community and the strong record of delivery by the Borough Council team and finally I’d like to thank the people of Bishopstoke Botley and Burseldon, Eastleigh town and Fair Oak, Horton Heath, Hamble and Hedge End, Netley and West End.
“You know by now we’ve been here for nearly 20 years. This is where I brought up my family. Eastleigh is a beautiful part of the country with friendly people and many good friends it really is a great honour to be elected as your representative tonight. I now intend to be a hardworking constituency MP and a strong voice for every person in this community.
” Today you’ve given me a mandate to work to defend our countryside to continue to seek to bring jobs and growth to the area to fight to continue cutting taxes for ordinary working people to defend our public services and to ensure a fair deal for our pensioners and this is what I will do.
“Finally tonight is a great might for Liberal Democrats nationally. A strong signal of support for Nick Clegg an affirmation of our role for working for the national interest within the coalition and a huge boost for our party’s mission in government to deliver a stronger economy with a fairer society so everyone can get on in life.
“What about the bedroom tax?” shouted another heckler
“ To those who said the Liberal Democrats won’t win here, they can’t do it – we have done it and we will do it again. The Liberal Democrats are winning here.”
Diana James of Ukip said:
“I want to echo all of the thanks that Mike’s just given but I also want to applaud the Eastleigh community. I may have come second this evening but as voters have delivered on humongous political shock. No longer will Ukip be excluded from surveys and polls we will now always be included in interviews.”
Maria Hutchings the Conservative candidate said:
“ I’d like to thank the returning officer and the staff who worked so hard to get this election done and also to the police I’d also like to thank the people of Eastleigh who voted for me and put their belief in me I’d like to thank the absolutely incredible campaign team I’ve had and the hundreds of activists who have come out to help support our campaign”
“ I would just like to say this was a very clean campaign and to thank the other candidates and obviously to congratulate Mike for his win. I’d like to thank those who mean so much to me my husband my children and to say I wish the very best to the people of Eastleigh.”
John O’Farrell who stood for Labour said:
“Well I did tell the Labour party that I usually lose elections!
“I would also like to thank the police the staff which have been doing the count everyone in the polling station san congratulation to Mike on a resounding victory and I’d like echo the comments from other candidates about it being a good clean contest I d would like to thank my wife Jackie and my children who are here for enormous emotional support.”
“I’d like to thank everybody from the Labour party from Eastleigh Labour party and Southampton and the shadow cabinet MPs and the many activists who came from all over the country to help us make a difference”
“I’m sorry Eastleigh we neglected you over the last 20 years but I think we made up for it in the last three weeks”
“Politics is not about leaflets or knocking on doors or sound bites on the news – it’s about hospitals, it’s about schools – things that matter to the man in the street. I believe the Labour Party is in the best interests of Eastleigh people and in the best interests of the whole of the United Kingdom.”
Eastleigh News would like to congratulate Mike Thornton on his win and we wish him good luck in his parliamentary career.
Stephen would also like to personally anyone who has read this far!



