
Eastleigh Borough Council Leader Keith House has jokingly dismissed calls for independent scrutiny of the behind-schedule and over-budget One Horton Heath 2,500-home housing project, saying, “We’ve got the best bat hotels in the country,” pointing to the project’s infrastructure achievements to date, which include, among other things, bat boxes, but to date, no houses.
Councillor House was responding to a motion proposed by Councillor Gin Tidridge for an independent review of the One Horton Heath development off Allington Lane during a meeting of the full council (Nov 27).
Cllr Tidridge pointed out significant increases in project costs, from £148 million to £320 million, and the absence of a forecast for projected income in a recent Audit and Resources Committee report. She highlighted the council’s monthly spending of £326,330 for a project that she said could potentially result in a £45 million loss.
Replying to Cllr Tidridge, Cllr Keith House acknowledged that recent economic shocks and rising construction costs had impacted negatively on the project. He praised the local authority’s commitment to deliver high-quality housing with superior standards, contrasting the council’s approach with the profit-driven private sector. House acknowledged this approach meant a reduced profit margin but expressed confidence in managing the project’s finances overall.
Cllr House dismissed the Independent and Conservative opposition group’s concerns, accusing them of ‘nimbyism’ in opposing housing developments without clear alternatives. He defended the project’s ‘robust’ business case, accommodating adjustments for the evolving property market and the unique model of self-delivery.
Despite acknowledging delays, Cllr House insisted it was right to take the time to get the project right, presenting One Horton Heath as an exemplar scheme. He rejected the motion for an independent review, citing existing scrutiny mechanisms and the project’s positive impact on housing accessibility.
During the debate Lib Dem councillors chose to focus on the long-term benefits that One Horton Heath can deliver rather than the medium-term financial risks that Cllr Tidridge is clearly concerned could sink it and Cllr Tidridge’s motion was lost.
Independent councillor Karen Caws voiced her frustration with her Lib Dem colleagues:
“This [motion] is about costs but where are the answers? Cllr Tidridge is talking about cost versus revenue. It doesn’t seem to be adding up and nobody is saying anything about those figures. It seems to me like a lot of heads being buried in the sand. I’m not convinced that this is a viable endeavour for the council.”
Cllr Caws warned that the Council could be risking bankruptcy and while the council is currently not facing bankruptcy it has a lot in common with councils that are.
Interest Rates and Financial Burden
It should be noted that the £320 million cost is only projected up to the end of 2024. The total debt is likely to be many times this amount, especially with the addition of an extra 350 houses that had been announced by the leader earlier in the meeting.The current monthly interest payments of £326,000 on £148 million borrowing are based on interest rates, some of which will have been as low as 1.79%. The additional approved £178 million of borrowing will be financed at a much higher rate, as will the short-term debt that needs to be refinanced as the loans fall due. Current Public Works Loan Board (PWLB) fixed standard rates are all over 5%, which would add at least £741,000 a month to interest payments. All this is in addition to the council’s borrowing on its commercial property portfolio which is currently costing £1.2 million pm. The £837 million total borrowing means the council will be spending more on servicing debt each month than on providing services and the combined debt will be many more times the council’s current revenue.
Councillor House’s Past Opposition and Shift in Stance
Cllr House may have branded opposition members ‘nimbys’ but Eastleigh News readers will remember that in 2014 the Liberal Democrats were also opposed to development on the site, accusing Ukip of planning a “4,000 house village off Allington Lane.” which was strongly denied by Ukip. Eastleigh’s Lib Dem MP Mike Thornton even launched an online petition to “stop Ukip’s 4000 house chaos” At the time, Cllr House told Eastleigh News that development on Allington Lane would erode the greenbelt by merging village’s as well as causing traffic problems in an environmentally sensitive area. Showing remarkable foresight, Cllr House said it would take over 10 years before the site could deliver any housing. Readers may also recall that when challenged to provide evidence of Ukip’s plan, Mike Thornton had to admit he had none and issued an apology.
Council Reliance on Audit and Scrutiny Mechanisms
Critics have argued that the private sector would have built homes sooner, driven by the need to provide value for money to shareholders. Cllr House, referred to the 130,000 residents of Eastleigh as the council’s ‘shareholders,’ raising questions about whether they too, are getting value for money.
To try and find an answer to this question Eastleigh News turned to the Council’s audit report. The Leader recently told a BBC reporter that “our auditors are all over this” and while that’s true, there’s an absence of up-to-date commentary. A report on OHH by the internal auditor is still ‘in progress’ and the external independent auditor, Ernst Young, has yet to publish their report for year ending March 2022. Ernst Young gave a verbal update to Audit and Resources committee in July but no recording of the update has been uploaded to the council website and the printed minutes only noted that OHH was under discussion with no details of what was said..
Concerns Raised by Auditors
The latest audit report therefore is now over two years old and predates recent rises in interest rates and costs. In the report, the auditors urge the Council to carry out a ‘going concern’ assessment “that is proportionate the the significant risks it faces” and concluded there was a ‘material uncertainty’ relating to the Council’s ability to refinance borrowing as it falls due.
Earlier this year the auditors released a planning report update date January 2023 which warned…
Increasing interest rates, coupled with high very levels of inflation, have put significant pressure on the Council’s finances over the medium-term. It is therefore essential that its financial plans are revised to mitigate the impact of this and ensure future financial sustainability.
The Leader cited the council’s recent participation in the Local Government Association’s Corporate Peer Challenge as further evidence of independent scrutiny but examination of previous reports suggest the review is more of a networking opportunity than an inspection.
The Leader also referenced the Audit and Resources (A&R) committee, which is usually the first stop for scrutiny of council matters, but as it is predominantly composed of members of the ruling Lib Dem group – currently ten of the eleven members are Lib Dem – this has led to accusations that the Lib Dems are ‘marking their own homework.’
An Alternative Proposal
A source with inside knowledge of the OHH programme, who spoke to Eastleigh News on condition of anonymity, has suggested that the council could still revert its original plan of selling off the site to developers as fully serviced plots. There were many expressions of interest from builders in 2017 and the profit generated would pay off the debt and stop the excessive interest payments while still delivering houses on a site that the private sector would have otherwise struggled to bring forward.
Lingering Questions
Leader Keith House’s dismissal and the subsequent defeat of the motion raise questions about the Council’s approach to scrutiny. In a positive step the Council has decided to strengthen the A&R committee by co-opting two new members and increasing the frequency of updates on the One Horton Heath (OHH) project but the decision not to proceed with an independent review will leave lingering questions about financial transparency and the project’s medium-term sustainability.

