Council under fire: Auditors raise fraud concerns, MP demands investigation

A report by the Borough Council’s external auditors, raising the possibility of fraud, is set to be considered at a meeting tonight along with the council’s response to the allegations.

This latest report comes less than a month after the government issued a Best Value Notice to Eastleigh Borough Council due to concerns about its financial management, debt levels, and governance structures.

Auditors Ernst & Young’s update on the council’s value for money, identifys risks of “significant weaknesses.”

Among the risks identified were concerns over the level of debt; the impact of increased borrowing costs on the Council’s financial sustainability and value-for-money concerns over the acquisition of Chalcroft Solar Park in 2021. The council is reported to have paid £9.5m for the land, which was later valued at only £710k.

The report also identified risks with the One Horton Heath (OHH) mass housing project as a result of the whistleblowing reports received by the council. It also questioned the capacity of the council’s Internal Audit service to investigate the whistleblower allegations, despite a recent assurance by the council leader to the BBC that ‘our auditors are all over this.’

The report also highlights a whistleblower complaint made by a council employee in March last year. The complaint, seen by Eastleigh News, highlighted significant concerns about the financial management and decision-making processes at the council. There were also criticisms of alleged poor financial judgment leading to job losses, ambiguity in the council’s role as a property developer or Registered Provider, and specific scrutiny of the OHH project and the lack of external scrutiny.

There was also criticism of the council’s commercial portfolio, pointing out the number of vacant buildings and questioning the business plan behind some acquisitions.

More specifically, the whistleblower questioned the process by which the council procured the services of consultants for the OHH scheme and the justification for some of the high fees and salaries they are being paid.

In a written response, also due to be discussed at tonight’s meeting, the council said that following a full investigation, only two of the concerns raised were found to be valid. These related to procurement arrangements and a breach in compliance with legislation and regulation.

Regarding the risk of fraud, the council said:

“There is an inherent risk that fraud may not be detected, and Internal Audit has articulated that it cannot categorically say that there has been no material fraud. However, it has appropriately reported weaknesses in control that can lead to an increase in the risk of fraud and made appropriate recommendations. Internal Audit has noted, however, that the in-depth audit testing performed as part of the whistleblower review and other wider assurance reviews have identified no instances of fraud.”

But the EY report concluded:

“Neither we nor the council are able to determine there has been no material non-compliance with laws and regulation or fraud.”

Speaking to the Daily Echo, Eastleigh’s MP Paul Holmes said:

“My worst fears about this project have appeared to materialise.

The report is damning in its criticism of Eastleigh Borough Council’s inability to manage the One Horton Heath development.”Concerns range from the spiraling costs and lack of expertise to carry out this project but also highlight EY’s inability to determine whether fraud and improper compliance with laws and regulations has occurred.”

The MP also called for a full investigation into OHH and said he would be bringing the matter to the attention of Simon Hoare, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Local Government.

As previously reported, OHH is set to deliver around 3,000 homes at a cost of £481m. It was revealed in November that the project was costing Eastleigh over £300,000 a month in interest payments. However, despite the costs and after six years of costs, the site is yet to deliver any houses.

The Audit and Resources Committee is due to meet to night at 6.15pm, Tuesday 16 January at Ground Floor, Eastleigh House, Upper Market Street, Eastleigh, SO50 9YN. The meeting is open to the public.