
Eastleigh MP Liz Jarvis has voted in favour of legalising assisted dying for terminally ill adults in a historic House of Commons vote. However, Paul Holmes, MP for Hamble Valley, which also covers part of the Eastleigh borough, opposed the measure, citing concerns over the potential risks to vulnerable individuals.
The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, introduced by Labour MP Kim Leadbeater, passed its first parliamentary hurdle with a majority of 55, as MPs voted 330 to 275 in support. The bill proposes allowing terminally ill individuals, expected to die within six months, to seek medical assistance to end their lives under strict safeguards.
Paul Holmes explained his decision, stating: “While I understand the deep compassion behind this bill, I could not in good conscience support it. My concerns remain that legalising assisted dying could lead to the elderly, disabled, or vulnerable people being placed under subtle but significant pressure to end their lives. Instead of changing the law, we should focus on investing in world-class palliative care for those nearing the end of life.”
Liz Jarvis shared her reasons for supporting the bill in a letter to constituents, referencing the death of her mother earlier this year after a seven-year battle with Alzheimer’s. She acknowledged the importance of ensuring people receive “utmost compassion and dignity” in their final months and expressed hope that the debate would lead to improved palliative and mental health care.
Jarvis wrote: “Having considered the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in detail, I agree with its fundamental aim: to help give adults over 18 who have been diagnosed with a terminal illness, who have less than six months to live, and who have the capacity to make their own decision, the choice of how and when to alleviate their suffering.”
She added that it was “absolutely vital” for proper safeguards to be in place to prevent coercion or exploitation of vulnerable adults, noting that the bill would undergo further scrutiny and debate before progressing.
The government maintained a neutral stance, allowing MPs a free vote. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer supported the bill, as did 15 cabinet ministers, including Chancellor Rachel Reeves. However, Health Secretary Wes Streeting and Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood were among eight cabinet members voting against.
The debate in Parliament lasted over four hours, with more than 160 MPs requesting to speak. Leadbeater described current laws as “failing” terminally ill people and highlighted cases of individuals who had died in agony or taken their own lives due to a lack of options. Critics, however, argued the bill’s safeguards might not be enough to prevent abuse or coercion.
Outside Parliament, supporters of the bill, including terminally ill broadcaster Dame Esther Rantzen, described the vote as a “historic moment,” though opponents gathered to express their fears over its implications.
If the law is ultimately passed, England and Wales would join countries such as the Netherlands and Canada in permitting assisted dying under strict conditions.The bill now moves to further scrutiny in the Commons and Lords, with amendments likely before any final decision.

