Victory for residents as council blocks Pear Tree development

pic: Google

Residents in Boorley Green are celebrating a major victory after Eastleigh Borough Council threw out plans to build six houses on land next to the popular Pear Tree Inn. The controversial proposal was slammed by the council for threatening a cherished local pub and its green space.

The land, once listed as an Asset of Community Value (ACV), had been protected until its status lapsed in 2022. Despite fierce opposition from locals and Botley Parish Council’s failed attempt to renew the ACV, developer Dorrington Homes resubmitted plans after withdrawing a similar application last December.

The council’s decision to refuse permission came down to five reasons. They said the development would urbanise countryside land, breach local and national planning rules, and ruin the character of the area. The loss of the garden would also cripple the Pear Tree Inn’s role as a community hub. To make matters worse, no evidence was provided to show future residents wouldn’t suffer from noise and smells from the nearby wastewater station, railway, and the pub itself.

On top of that, the developers failed to meet strict biodiversity requirements and didn’t address the environmental impact on protected areas like the Solent Complex and the New Forest.

Objections were received from 334 people. Paul Cartwright, a resident, wrote, “The Pear Tree public house and its outside space consisting of a beer garden and children’s play area is the only location within safe walking distance (has pavement and crossing points) for residents of the Boorley Park and Boorley Gardens estates to take their children to play and also enjoy hot food and alcohol. The other public houses within a couple of miles of the estates mentioned have to be reached by car, as they are either too far to walk with children or do not have a pavement from the estate to the public house.”

Rachel Spink said, “I live opposite the Pear Tree and object for a number of reasons, most of which are the same as they were for the previous planning application on this site. Firstly, the land is designated countryside and needs to be protected as such. While this is addressed in the Design and Access Statement, the reasoning is weak and the treatment of the surrounding area should not be used as a precedent — in any case this small gap in development should be protected even more strongly.”

Emily Wyatt, another local resident, wrote: “The Pear Tree is a fantastic pub that caters for ALL age groups, from babies to the elderly. The pub itself is run by the most amazing team who have the public’s interests at heart, the landlord and landlady are the best. They often do charity fundraisers which help local charities promote their hard work. Taking away the garden would destroy the hard work the landlord and landlady have done to make it something appreciated by all, while minimising space for families to enjoy during nice weather periods.”

Stonegate Inns, which owns the Pear Tree, has insisted the land was “surplus to needs” and argued the pub could survive without it. Nick Rowland-Hill from Stonegate has previously stated, “The continued viability of The Pear Tree Inn is a priority for Stonegate, and it is our intention that the pub will continue to serve the community for many years to come.”

But residents were not convinced, claiming the pub’s unique charm lies in its outdoor space. Now, with the application rejected, campaigners are urging for the land’s ACV status to be reinstated to protect it from future threats.