Angry protesters storm out of council meeting over alpaca decision

‘Upset and disappointed’ supporters of Russells stables have vowed to fight on

Angry protesters stormed out of a council meeting last night (27 January) in frustration over the decision to revoke grazing rights for the long-established Russell’s Equestrian Centre and transfer them to Hensting Alpacas. Supporters of the 50 -year-old stables have criticised the council’s handling of the issue and accuse it of ducking a public consultation

The Hedge End, West End, and Botley (HEWEB) local area committee meeting at the Berry Theatre turned into a showdown as around 24 staunch supporters of Russell’s Equestrian Centre braved Storm Herminia to fight for the stables’ survival. But their pleas fell on deaf ears as the council rubber-stamped a 10-year contract for Hensting Alpacas.

Supporters voice concerns

Four speakers took to the microphone to defend Russell’s, with environmental educator Yarrow Townsend calling out the council’s claims that alpacas would boost biodiversity. “There’s no biodiversity report, no consultation with Natural England—where’s the evidence?” she demanded.

Sue Carpenter, trustee of the Epona Trust, warned the alpacas could pose health and safety risks. “What happens when an alpaca escapes or carries a disease? What about dog walkers, horse riders, or children in the park? This hasn’t been thought through,” she said.

Carol Boulton, founder of Russell’s and a former Liberal Democrat borough councillor, blasted the council’s fast-tracking of the alpaca scheme. “Why was this business given an easier ride than others? There’s been no scrutiny,” she said.

Verity Tidmarsh, co-owner of Russell’s, accused the council of turning its back on a community staple. “They’ve sold out a local business that’s served this community for decades,” she said. “How can the council rebuild trust after this? The 4,000 people who signed our petition want answers.”

Walkout follows council statement

Tempers flared as HEWEB Chair Councillor Cynthia Garton began to read out a lengthy council statement claiming they’d “supported” Russell’s for years with subsidised grazing licence fees, rent-free periods, and payment plans, The public gallery erupted in gasps and cries of “No!” as Carol Boulton, tried to respond, only to be shut down with a curt, “You’ve had your say.”

The visibly frustrated supporters then rose and left the meeting en masse, with one supporter calling out, “What an absolute waste of time,” as they exited, leaving the public gallery almost empty.

Councillor Garton continued reading the council’s statement, outlining the timeline of events, which included HEWEB councillors being consulted about the alpaca proposal in October, the granting of a 10-year licence to Hensting Alpacas in December, and Russell’s being notified of the decision with over four months’ notice. The council also said they had offered Russell’s a goodwill grant to purchase hay and feed for up to seven horses as an alternative to grazing, which an independent vet assessed as a suitable solution.

“The council has to consider what is globally best for the residents of Eastleigh Borough,” the statement concluded.

Protestors’ response outside the meeting

Outside the meeting, emotions ran high as campaigners blasted the council’s decision. Carol Boulton didn’t mince her words: “I couldn’t sit and listen to that rubbish—it was absolute lies.” Verity Tidmarsh, slammed the council’s “goodwill” support, comparing their offer of hay for the horses to “taking away a playground and handing out extra milk and apples.”

Campaigner Kathy McColl said she was “bitterly upset and disappointed,” adding, “They introduced a new business into the park with no public knowledge or scrutiny, and that is wrong. Whether it be a horse or an alpaca, it doesn’t matter—it’s wrong.”

Local businessman Mark Smith, who sponsors one of Russell’s horses, was equally scathing: “The council’s fast-tracking of this deal shows they can’t be trusted—they’ve lost my vote.”

One supporter poured scorn on the council’s claim to be working with the stables “There’s been one meeting” they said.

Council’s alpaca plan hits a snag

Meanwhile, Hensting Alpacas—the business at the heart of the controversy—have hit a snag. Their move to Allington Lane, originally set for January 7, has been delayed after the council say they need a new licence to train and exhibit animals – even though they already have a licence from Winchester City Council. They’ve now announced they won’t be moving in until after February 14.

Although the council has made it clear that it is not minded to reverse its decision, campaigners have vowed to continue the fight to save their beloved stables and plan to pursue legal advice.