MP accuses County Council of ‘shady deal’ in quarry U-turn

Paul Holmes MP speaking to BBC prior to start of hearing Pic: BBC via LNP

Hamble Valley’s Conservative MP Paul Holmes has accused Hampshire County Council of making a “shady deal” after it unexpectedly withdrew all objections to a controversial gravel quarry proposal on the first day of a public planning appeal.

The independent planning inspector’s inquiry into Cemex’s application to extract gravel from the former Hamble Airfield opened in Winchester on Monday (1 April), but proceedings took a dramatic turn when county council officers declared they would no longer be contesting the application.

The U-turn by Hampshire County Council (HCC) has sparked outrage among local campaigners and prompted an extraordinary intervention by Holmes, who said he had been misled and was now calling for the inquiry to be suspended.

“This was at complete odds with written communications to me by the leader of Hampshire County Council, and officers who assured me they were defending the stance that the quarry should not be granted permission,” Holmes said in a statement. “I am currently in discussions over the next steps we should take, including requesting that the planning inspector suspend his hearing until we can learn more about the shady deal made between HCC and Cemex.”

He added: “It is not right to abdicate responsibility for decisions and to hide behind lawyers and sham public hearings as I believe HCC have done this week.”

The planning application by building materials giant Cemex was originally rejected by Hampshire County Council’s Regulatory Committee in May 2024 following more than 5,000 objections from residents, schools, businesses and local councils. Opponents cited concerns over air pollution, traffic, ecological damage and the impact on Hamble village life.

The site, a former World War II grass airfield, has long been used for informal recreation by the local community and lies close to two schools, a surgery, residential streets and several sports and sailing facilities.

Since Cemex appealed the refusal in November 2024, Hamble Parish Council and the Hamble Peninsula Residents’ Group (HPRG) have formed the Peninsular Defence Group and raised tens of thousands of pounds to fund legal representation at the appeal.

Campaigners were stunned to learn at the opening of the inquiry that HCC had reversed its position. Outside the hearing at HCC headquarters in Winchester, objectors lined the streets, including pupils from Hamble School.

Eastleigh Borough Council, which is not the minerals authority but has supported the opposition case, is understood to be maintaining its objection to the development.

No explanation for HCC’s decision has yet been made public. Holmes said he had written to the council’s chief executive demanding answers.

The inquiry is expected to continue for several days. Cemex has argued that the site is allocated in Hampshire’s minerals plan and has claimed its plans meet all required environmental and traffic safeguards.